News:

Welcome to Wittenberg!

Main Menu
Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - Sir Lüc

#2
Quote from: mximo on February 18, 2024, 09:08:18 PM2/3 of the Senats is also 5 (5,28 rounded to 5)

2/3 of the Senats has always been interpreted as requiring 6/8, and not rounded down to 5; 5/8 is by definition not at least 2/3.
#3
Moved as requested.
#4
Personally, the A-X should not only have the right to request an advisory opinion from the CpI -- if anything they should probably be the one Government official that's primarily in charge of those, just as the MinFin (and not the Seneschal) has been in charge of the Budget for a few years now. Besides, the Seneschal has the implicit right to also request an advisory opinion by D.2.1.

(Also, there's a typo in that section of the OrgLaw -- Seneschal)
#5
Apologies for the delay (very busy last ten days, barely checked Witt), the bill has now been moved to committee as requested.
#6
Quote from: þerxh Sant-Enogat on February 10, 2024, 02:19:22 AM
Quote from: Sir Lüc on February 06, 2024, 06:14:52 PMAnyhow, my opinion is that the bill satisfies the requirements of Lex.D.2.8.3 in form and function.

Is there any particular reason why the louis has been decimalised? Also, very minor note, there's a typo ("Revue") just before the balance changes.
Thanks Sir Lüc
Now edited to use sexagesimal system and correct typo

Thank you, and approved.
#7
There's a small thing that needs fixing, D.2.1 doesn't read as it currently stands on the bill, that's only the final sentence. Otherwise I'd say this version works, sign me up.
#8
I would probably replace the old weirdly-worded bit with a broad provision that the Seneschal may perform any official act on behalf of their ministers; and the latter new part with a new, explicit provision that the Seneschal may at any time name a Deputy Minister to be Acting Minister, until the Seneschal or the absentee Minister publicly declare otherwise, or the absentee Minister is dismissed. (The ability of the Seneschal to appoint a Deputy Minister would be implied by the first bit anyway.)
#9
El Funal/The Hopper / Re: BHAID: Effective Altruism Act
February 09, 2024, 04:54:20 AM
Moved out of committee as requested.
#10
Quote from: Breneir Tzaracomprada on February 07, 2024, 02:15:42 PMAlso, can this be moved out of the CRL as this seems more appropriate for the Hopper? @Sir Lüc

Do I go ahead with this still?
#11
Anyhow, my opinion is that the bill satisfies the requirements of Lex.D.2.8.3 in form and function.

Is there any particular reason why the louis has been decimalised? Also, very minor note, there's a typo ("Revue") just before the balance changes.
#12
Gladly!

For the record, the process I'm following is to click on "Move Topic", then select the CRL board as destination, do not post a redirection topic, and change the title of the thread to add the [CRL] prefix.

(Ideally, this will be done again when the bill is moved to the Hopper archives.)
#14
I must point out that for some reason the former Seneschal has disappeared from the list of MCs during the second Clark, thus making it seem the VoC failed 81-85 as his 17 seats are missing.
#15
El Funal/The Hopper / Re: A-X CRL Alternates
January 31, 2024, 10:42:12 AM
Quote from: Breneir Tzaracomprada on January 30, 2024, 01:05:59 PMGood point. Do you think I should remove it as it is redundant? Also, co-sponsor? 😀

Sure! I think the provision is kinda redundant, but also we should probably-eventually-ideally review that other D.2.1 provision so that its meaning and scope get a bit clearer.