Chapter 5: A Confession in Silence
The abbey sat atop a wind-swept cliff, its stone façade etched with centuries of sea salt and silence. A quiet refuge, even now, when suspicion clung to the island like fog. Brother Andreu dal Cjef tended its garden, his hands among thyme and rosemary, as if untouched by the storm gathering around him.
Investigator Marcus Lucéu approached with quiet steps. Caspàr stayed at the gate—on Lucéu's request. This conversation needed to be undisturbed, direct, and unclouded by performance.
Brother Andreu looked up, eyes serene. "Good evening, Investigator."
Lucéu nodded. "I'd like to speak with you. Not as an officer of the Cort Pü Inalt. As a man seeking truth."
Andreu wiped his hands and gestured to a stone bench beneath a lemon tree. They sat in silence for a moment, the wind whistling gently through the branches.
Lucéu began without preamble.
"I believe you wrote the anonymous letter to Dr. Presteir. The threat."
Andreu did not flinch. "You believe correctly."
The calm admission hung in the air like a suspended bell note.
"Why didn't you deny it?" Lucéu asked.
"Because threats are not crimes. Not in Talossa, not in most courts of language. I warned her not to desecrate the sacred. I warned her because I feared what would come if she continued. But I did not kill her."
"You used the phrase 'velvet footnotes.' The same as in your reply to El Tamlaltzün. The same as in the threat."
"I am a creature of habit," Andreu said with a wan smile. "My metaphors wear familiar shoes."
Lucéu regarded him for a long moment. "Why did you write to her anonymously, if you believed your warning to be righteous?"
Andreu looked away. "Because she would have mocked it. Because truth is rarely received in the voice it needs. Sometimes it must arrive in disguise."
Lucéu nodded. "Fair. But the coin—do you own one?"
Andreu shook his head. "No. I always found the coins to be... ornamental. I do not traffic in symbols. Only words."
Lucéu studied his face for cracks. Found none.
"But you did see her that night."
This time, Andreu hesitated.
"Yes," he said eventually. "I saw her on the path by the olive grove. We spoke."
Lucéu's heart beat a little faster. "What about?"
"I begged her—again—to reconsider her speech. She was polite. She listened. But her eyes had already moved on. She had made peace with being a martyr, Marcus."
The use of his name startled Lucéu.
"I didn't tell the truth before," Andreu continued. "Because I feared it would cast me as the villain. But you already knew, didn't you?"
"I suspected," Lucéu replied.
Andreu stood and brushed dust from his cassock. "But I am not the villain. Nor am I the hero. Elinor died because she threatened the wrong person's legacy. Someone who had more to lose than just ideas."
Lucéu rose, brow furrowed. "Who?"
Andreu looked past him, toward the sea. "I don't know. But if you want answers, you'll need to ask the wrong question. Who stood to gain if Elinor wasn't there to speak? Not just ideologically. Politically."
Lucéu's mind began to churn. Ventrutx. Arosçeu. Even Miroslav?
He stepped back. "Thank you for your honesty, Brother."
"One last thing," Andreu said. "Elinor once told me that the only true language is courage. I believe that now more than ever."
⸻
Later — The Town Archives
Night had fallen. Lucéu returned to the cultural center, drawn by something he hadn't yet understood—an itch in the back of his mind that hadn't stopped since reading Elinor's letter.
He flipped through the festival program again. Her keynote was to be the final address. But the slot had been reassigned—after her death—to none other than... Madóra Ventrutx.
He checked the scheduling logs. The change had been requested that morning, hours before Elinor was found dead.
Lucéu's breath caught.
She hadn't died at 10 p.m., as originally believed. She may have died earlier—while the festival still bustled, while no one would notice her absence.
Which meant someone knew she'd be gone.
He grabbed his coat and turned to Caspàr, asleep on the couch in the corner.
"Wake up," Lucéu said. "We're going to pay the Seneschal's cousin a second visit."
The abbey sat atop a wind-swept cliff, its stone façade etched with centuries of sea salt and silence. A quiet refuge, even now, when suspicion clung to the island like fog. Brother Andreu dal Cjef tended its garden, his hands among thyme and rosemary, as if untouched by the storm gathering around him.
Investigator Marcus Lucéu approached with quiet steps. Caspàr stayed at the gate—on Lucéu's request. This conversation needed to be undisturbed, direct, and unclouded by performance.
Brother Andreu looked up, eyes serene. "Good evening, Investigator."
Lucéu nodded. "I'd like to speak with you. Not as an officer of the Cort Pü Inalt. As a man seeking truth."
Andreu wiped his hands and gestured to a stone bench beneath a lemon tree. They sat in silence for a moment, the wind whistling gently through the branches.
Lucéu began without preamble.
"I believe you wrote the anonymous letter to Dr. Presteir. The threat."
Andreu did not flinch. "You believe correctly."
The calm admission hung in the air like a suspended bell note.
"Why didn't you deny it?" Lucéu asked.
"Because threats are not crimes. Not in Talossa, not in most courts of language. I warned her not to desecrate the sacred. I warned her because I feared what would come if she continued. But I did not kill her."
"You used the phrase 'velvet footnotes.' The same as in your reply to El Tamlaltzün. The same as in the threat."
"I am a creature of habit," Andreu said with a wan smile. "My metaphors wear familiar shoes."
Lucéu regarded him for a long moment. "Why did you write to her anonymously, if you believed your warning to be righteous?"
Andreu looked away. "Because she would have mocked it. Because truth is rarely received in the voice it needs. Sometimes it must arrive in disguise."
Lucéu nodded. "Fair. But the coin—do you own one?"
Andreu shook his head. "No. I always found the coins to be... ornamental. I do not traffic in symbols. Only words."
Lucéu studied his face for cracks. Found none.
"But you did see her that night."
This time, Andreu hesitated.
"Yes," he said eventually. "I saw her on the path by the olive grove. We spoke."
Lucéu's heart beat a little faster. "What about?"
"I begged her—again—to reconsider her speech. She was polite. She listened. But her eyes had already moved on. She had made peace with being a martyr, Marcus."
The use of his name startled Lucéu.
"I didn't tell the truth before," Andreu continued. "Because I feared it would cast me as the villain. But you already knew, didn't you?"
"I suspected," Lucéu replied.
Andreu stood and brushed dust from his cassock. "But I am not the villain. Nor am I the hero. Elinor died because she threatened the wrong person's legacy. Someone who had more to lose than just ideas."
Lucéu rose, brow furrowed. "Who?"
Andreu looked past him, toward the sea. "I don't know. But if you want answers, you'll need to ask the wrong question. Who stood to gain if Elinor wasn't there to speak? Not just ideologically. Politically."
Lucéu's mind began to churn. Ventrutx. Arosçeu. Even Miroslav?
He stepped back. "Thank you for your honesty, Brother."
"One last thing," Andreu said. "Elinor once told me that the only true language is courage. I believe that now more than ever."
⸻
Later — The Town Archives
Night had fallen. Lucéu returned to the cultural center, drawn by something he hadn't yet understood—an itch in the back of his mind that hadn't stopped since reading Elinor's letter.
He flipped through the festival program again. Her keynote was to be the final address. But the slot had been reassigned—after her death—to none other than... Madóra Ventrutx.
He checked the scheduling logs. The change had been requested that morning, hours before Elinor was found dead.
Lucéu's breath caught.
She hadn't died at 10 p.m., as originally believed. She may have died earlier—while the festival still bustled, while no one would notice her absence.
Which meant someone knew she'd be gone.
He grabbed his coat and turned to Caspàr, asleep on the couch in the corner.
"Wake up," Lucéu said. "We're going to pay the Seneschal's cousin a second visit."